"The Savoy Palace is an impressive property in a beautiful location, but after our stay, I have mixed feelings about whether it truly delivers the luxury experience its reputation and price point promise.
Location and Setting
Let's start with what the hotel gets right. Its location is excellent. It is within walking distance of downtown Funchal, yet far enough away from the center to offer a little breathing room. Directly across the street is a bank with an ATM, along with cafes and restaurants, making it very convenient for guests.
The hotel overlooks the water, and one of its most beautiful features is the lush greenery growing and cascading down the building's many floors. It creates a dramatic, almost tropical atmosphere and gives the property a distinctive visual appeal. I particularly loved this feature.
The Staff and Dining
The concierge staff were absolutely outstanding. They were helpful, knowledgeable, and consistently went above and beyond. The front desk staff were also very accommodating and helpful.
The evening turndown service staff were equally lovely. They were warm, attentive, and genuinely wonderful.
Breakfast at The Reserve was another highlight. The food, impeccable service, atmosphere, and views were exactly what one would expect from a hotel of this caliber. It was an exceptional experience.
Unfortunately, that same level of hospitality did not carry over to the buffet restaurant. Something as simple as requesting a takeaway cup of coffee to enjoy after breakfast became an ongoing issue. I asked every morning and was repeatedly told I could not take one out. It seems like such a small thing, but at a luxury hotel, these little gestures of hospitality matter.
The Décor and Furnishings
While the architecture and overall scale of the property are impressive, I found some of the interior design choices dated. The abundance of mauve and pink carpeting and sofas gives parts of the hotel a distinctly late-20th-century aesthetic. Rather than feeling contemporary and timeless, some spaces feel as though they haven't been refreshed in quite some time.
For a hotel positioning itself in the luxury market, I would have expected a more current and sophisticated design aesthetic. The property has beautiful architectural elements and a spectacular setting, and I think updating the furnishings, fabrics, and color palette would elevate the overall experience considerably.
The Room, Amenities and Fragrance
The Bvlgari toiletries provided in the bathroom were another disappointment. The fragrance was overwhelmingly strong. I was unable to use them, and even when my husband used the products, the scent lingered so intensely after he stepped out of the shower that it filled the entire room. Luxury toiletries should enhance the experience, not overwhelm it. Offering a fragrance-free alternative would be a thoughtful accommodation.
Even more concerning was the overwhelming fragrance being diffused throughout the hallways outside the guest rooms. The scent was extremely strong and difficult to escape. I am not asthmatic or particularly prone to respiratory sensitivities, but the fragrance irritated my nasal passages and caused throat irritation. Between the heavily scented hallways and the overpowering Bvlgari toiletries in the bathroom, the overall fragrance experience was simply too much.
A luxury hotel should recognize that not all guests enjoy heavily scented environments and that fragrances can cause genuine physical discomfort. A neutral, clean-smelling environment would be far more welcoming.
We also had issues with our room requests. Despite asking that the feather pillows be removed, they continued to be left in our room.
The laundry service was another disappointment. Our clothes were returned damp and with an extremely strong fragrance. We requested that they be washed again without detergent or fragrance.
Sustainability and Guest Experience
I also have mixed feelings about the hotel's approach to towel reuse. I absolutely support hotels making responsible environmental choices and conserving resources. In fact, I particularly appreciated the motion-sensor lighting in the upstairs hallways. As the elevator doors opened onto our floor, the lights immediately illuminated. It's a simple but clever way to conserve energy without compromising the guest experience.
However, repeatedly asking guests to reuse wet towels after showering feels like shifting the responsibility onto the guest while the hotel benefits from reduced laundry costs. At home, I am perfectly happy to hang up and reuse my towels. But when staying at a luxury hotel, I don't think guests should be made to feel guilty for wanting a fresh, dry towel. There are better ways for hotels to communicate and implement sustainability.
Final Thoughts
Madeira is a spectacular destination, and the Savoy Palace is a gorgeous property with a tremendous amount going for it. We genuinely appreciated the staff members who made our stay special, particularly the concierge team, front desk, and turndown service staff.
However, luxury is defined by more than beautiful surroundings, impressive facilities, recognizable toiletries brands, and a high price tag. It is defined by attention to detail, anticipating guest needs, accommodating individual preferences, and providing a consistently high level of service throughout the property.
The Savoy Palace got some things absolutely right. Unfortunately, other aspects of our stay did not live up to the expectations of a hotel of this caliber.
It is a beautiful hotel in a wonderful destination, but I believe there is room for improvement before I would consider it a truly exceptional luxury experience."