"I recently stayed at the Hotel Puerta America for a week and came away with mixed feelings. The hotel is a genuinely interesting concept, with each floor designed by a different world-renowned architect. It’s a feast for the eyes and unlike any other hotel I’ve stayed at. My room offered the most incredible view I’ve ever had from a hotel room, and the bed was, without a doubt, the comfiest I’ve ever slept in.
The location is also fantastic—it's surprisingly quiet and peaceful, despite being near one of Madrid's busiest roads. The soundproofing is excellent, and I never heard any traffic or other guests.
You'll find plenty of great restaurants and bars nearby, so you really don't need to venture far if you don't want to but there are excellent transport links nearby and taxis to and from the city centre are around 14€.
The staff were all friendly and helpful, and the hotel never felt overcrowded. It was easy to get a sun lounger by the pool, and the breakfast, while efficient, had the same limited options every morning, which got a bit repetitive after a week. The in-room toiletries were also a nice touch and felt specifically chosen to work well with the local water.
However, a few issues kept this from being a five-star experience. The most frustrating was the non-negotiable 50€ per-night deposit, which for our seven-night stay added up to a hefty 350€. This isn't mentioned anywhere during the booking process and feels like a massive oversight for anyone budgeting for their trip. The hotel should just take a credit card record like most others. Our room, while visually striking, was a bit impractical. The glass box toilet offered little privacy, and the "desk" was more of a decorative space than a functional workspace.
The style-over-substance theme continued with other small annoyances: the awnings were pinned up and couldn't be closed, so it was a constant battle between natural light and the blaring hot sun in the mornings. The wardrobe hangers were old and our clothes kept falling off, ending up in a heap. The sliding glass doors were so heavy they felt cumbersome.
For a five-star hotel, it was also surprising that there was no minibar, although the empty fridge was at least useful for stocking our own drinks.
Ultimately, the Hotel Puerta America felt more like a business hotel than a holiday destination. It seems a bit short-staffed, with employees often handling multiple roles. While it’s a unique and visually impressive place to stay, it doesn’t quite measure up to other five-star hotels I’ve seen in Madrid due to its impracticalities and odd policies. It’s an experience worth having for the design alone, but it won’t be for everyone."