"Some context: my wife and I booked a trip-of-a-lifetime style 2 week excursion through Greece, with stays at luxury properties in the Cyclades and Athens, using mainly points and miles accumulated over nearly a decade. Our hotels were mostly fantastic and we felt like we got what we paid for- until we got to Athens and our 3-night stay at the King George. That said, this is less a review of the hotel than is advice: there are VASTLY better values in Athens for your money. I'm sure there are many factors that go into a stay at a hotel like this one, and this is only based on our recent experience.
First, some positives:
The location is fantastic, and I would imagine that the view would be impressive, should you pay enough to have one.
The hotel is stately, elegant, and historic. It has the feel of being expensive, solid, and extremely well built, like a high-end German car or a fine Swiss watch.
The doormen are truly wonderful, helpful, and attentive.
There was a phone next to the toilet, which would have been extremely impressive in 1962.
Now to the less-than-stellar:
The room, which the staff seemed subtly reluctant to give us because we paid with points, was small to the point of being cramped. 1/3 of the already-small room was taken up with a large desk with an uncomfortable chair, and a large shelf-like protrusion, which I assume housed HVAC ductwork of some sort. No room that retails for $1000+ a night, anywhere in the world, should feel this small and uncomfortable.
There is no pool, spa, sauna, or even a lobby common area at the King George. However, as a guest, you are allowed to use these facilities at the much grander Gran Bretagne hotel directly next door. You’ll enjoy traipsing outside with your swimsuit, making your way through the GB’s more spacious and luxurious lobby, and slinking downstairs to the spa area while the GB guests sniff at the rabble from next door who only spent a $1,000 a night on their rooms.
Our room’s view, if it can be called that, was of an odd interior space with metal posts and what appeared to be bare light bulbs. Even with the drapes open, it was impossible to tell if it was day or night outside.
We purchased some truly outstanding street food in downtown Athens and brought it back to the hotel. However, since there wasn’t room (or chairs!) for two people to sit and eat comfortably in our tiny room, my wife and I opted to sit at a small corner table in what is ostensibly the King George’s lobby. Within 2 minutes, we were informed by the staff that this table was reserved for bar guests. Keep in mind, we were paying the equivalent of $1100 a night in Amex points to stay here.
About paying with points: my wife and I both noticed on more than one occasion that there seem to be two classes of guests at the King George: those who pay in cash and pony up $2k+ for a nicer room, and “guests” like us who are in smaller rooms and/or used points and are placed into luxurious broom closets.
No breakfast or meals of any kind were included with our stay, which also seemed to be related to our paying with points, as every other guest I saw while checking in was told that breakfast was included. This was the only hotel (out of 4) of our 2-week trip to not include breakfast, and it was also the most expensive.
There was no way to turn the bathroom lights on or off while you’re actually in the bathroom. The only light switch for the bathroom is next to the front door, or situated on either side of the bed.
The floors of the bathroom are very nice marble, which turn into an ice skating rink with the barest hint of moisture. Helpfully, it was impossible to take a shower in the oddly-situated tub/shower combo without completely drenching the floor.
TL;DR - for the price we paid for our TINY interior-view room- and yes, using points is still paying, despite what the front desk staff seemed to think- we could have booked a suite with a private balcony and an Acropolis view at one of the nicer boutique hotels in an even better location in the city. Learn from our experience. Even if money means nothing to you or someone else is paying, there are vastly better values in Athens."