Mykonos Theoxenia Boutique Hotel

"First of all, I have to say that the location of this hotel deserves a 5/5 as it is walking distance to all the restaurants and stores in Little Venice. However, considering it costs a minimum of $1,120 euros/night (for a basic room with a garden view), and it is supposed to be a 5-star property, it was disappointing. There's a huge pile of garbage bags and dead plant matter sitting in the garden (near the entrance) and it didn't move the entire week. There's also pieces of trash and cigarette buts strewn about in the gardens which really takes away from the look of the property. Five star hotels don't have trash and cigarette buts all over the grounds. The patio furniture (on our terrace) was old and the cushions were dirty. The cushions around the pool also need a good cleaning. The plants in the gardens have not been cared for and most of them look to be near death. All of the staff were very friendly, especially those who work in the restaurant - so no issues there. It just seems like one of those properties where they employ as few staff as possible and management is missing in action. All in all, the Theoxenia property needs a refresh, has limited amenities (only one pool and not much of a gym), and needs to step it up in terms of service if they want to be considered a true 5-star hotel. There are other 'Design Hotels' on the island that are truly worth the price they charge."

"Our stay in Mykonos was absolutely perfect. The location couldn’t be better — super walkable to everything, right in the middle of the action but still feels quaint and peaceful once you’re there. The property has a gorgeous pool, stunning views, and a relaxed vibe that makes it hard to leave. The car service from the airport and to the cruise port was really handy. The room was spotless, the shower had fantastic water pressure, and breakfast was outstanding — especially the fresh orange juice (truly the best I’ve ever had!). An all-around amazing stay with wonderful people and beautiful surroundings. Highly recommend!"

"Let me start out and say that I might stay at the Theoxenia again. It's location is perfect to get in and about Mykonos (and Mykonos Town!) You cannot beat this location as it's a short walk everywhere and easy to get a cab in/out for trips.. The hotel is very clean and the service is excellent. We had a waterfront room and the balcony alcove had great views. Nice pool area. So why only 3 stars? 1. This is NOT a 5 star hotel. It is a rehab'ed 60s hotel. The showers are quite literally closets with painted walls. There is a sink in front of the bed. And the only place to watch your television is laying in bed. There is an outdoor pool bar, but it closes in the early evening. While you can get a cocktail in the evening, there is no "bar." 2. There is no fitness center to speak of. The hotel literally described it as a "fully equipped gym with magnificent sea views." It is a small room with an unplugged treadmill, a stationary bike, and tension/pulley device that says "do not use." 5 star hotels have real fitness centers! I might return, but now I understand the real deal."